If you are trying to pick between these two chairs, here is the short answer. The Coleman Portable Camping Chair is the better chair to sit in for a long evening. The Cascade Mountain Tech is the better chair to carry to a site far from where you parked. Everything past that is detail hung on one trade: comfort under you versus weight on your shoulder.

I am 58, I live in Chattanooga, and I camp out of a 2017 Subaru Forester most weekends from April through late October, mostly Tennessee state parks and a few national forest campgrounds in western North Carolina. My dog Biscuit is a 45-pound Australian Shepherd mix who runs hot and gets cold the minute the sun drops. So a camp chair has to do two jobs for me. It has to hold me up for three hours after dinner, and it has to give Biscuit something to lean against while I read. I have used both of these chairs on real trips, not in a showroom.

Side by Side

Coleman Portable Camping ChairCascade Mountain Tech
Built-in cooler4-can cooler built into one armrestNo built-in cooler
Cupholder and pocketsMesh cup holder plus side pockets for keys, leash and phoneCarry bag and not much else
Seat width24-inch seat, solid backNarrower sling seat
Weight capacityFrame rated to 325 poundsLighter frame, and it flexes more under a heavy sitter
Comfort on hour threeCushioned seat and back, arms to push up fromFine for an hour, less fine when your hips want support
Weight3.5 kg on the listingLighter, and it feels lighter on the walk in
Packed sizeFolds into a long rectangleFolds into a carry bag you can sling over a shoulder
WarrantyThe listing states no manufacturer warrantyCoverage depends on where you buy it, so check before you order
SetupOpens like a standard quad chairOpens just as fast
Best forSitting for hours at a drive-in site with a drink in reachWalking in, packing small, staying out of the way
A person seated in a folding camp chair at a campsite reaching into the cooler built into the armrest, a tumbler in the mesh cup holder, and a medium-sized dog lying at their feet

Where Coleman Wins

Start with the arm. The Coleman has a 4-can cooler built into one armrest, a mesh cup holder, and side pockets on the other side. I know how that sounds. It sounds like a novelty until your second night, when the fire is down to coals, the dog has finally settled, and you want a cold drink without standing up and walking to the SUV. I have made that walk in the dark with a headlamp more times than I care to admit. The chair makes the walk unnecessary. Four cans is not a party. It is one evening, or two if you are pacing yourself. One Friday in June, at a state park outside Chattanooga, I put a can in that cooler at dusk with the air still thick and warm and pulled it out two hours later with water beaded on the side. Nothing dramatic happened. That is the point. It did the small job it was built to do, and I never left my seat.

Then there is the part you actually sit on. The seat is 24 inches wide, the back is solid, and the seat and back are cushioned. Width matters more as you get older, because a narrow sling seat puts your hips in a bind and you feel it in your low back by the second hour. The listing also puts a cushioned head rest at the top and rates the frame to 325 pounds. What I noticed most was the arms. At 58, with a knee that reminds me it exists, arms on a camp chair are not decoration. They are how I stand up without tipping the chair or asking Ray to haul me out of it. The head rest sounds like marketing until you lean back on it after a day of walking a dog. Ray is heavier than I am and that frame did not creak under him once all season. I did not load it to the rated limit and I would not claim to have. I did watch a grown man settle back into it after dinner without a sound out of the frame.

Where Cascade Mountain Tech Wins

The Cascade Mountain Tech earns its place on the other side of the ledger. It is lighter and it packs smaller, which sounds like a small thing until you are the one carrying it. At a walk-in site in the Cherokee National Forest, I have carried a chair a quarter mile down a gravel path with a dog leash in one hand and a dry bag on my back. The Coleman is 3.5 kg and shaped like a long rectangle. That is not unreasonable. It is also not the chair I want on my shoulder for a quarter mile. The Cascade folds into a carry bag you can sling and forget about. There is a stretch of that path where the gravel gives way to roots and the ground tilts to one side, and on that stretch the difference between a chair on a strap and a chair under your arm stops being theoretical. I felt it in my shoulder before I thought about it at all.

It also takes up less room in the back of the Forester. I camp with a dog crate, a cooler, a water jug, and a duffel, and floor space disappears fast. A chair that folds small slides into a gap. A chair that folds into a long rectangle has to go on top of something, and in my vehicle that means it rides across the top of the crate and slides every time I open the hatch to let Biscuit out. The Cascade is also the easier chair to leave in the vehicle all season for the trips you did not plan, the ones where the weather turns and you end up at a picnic table for an hour. It has a smaller footprint on a tent pad too, which matters when the pad is barely bigger than the tent.

The chair I reach for when the cooler is already open

A 4-can cooler in the arm, a mesh cup holder, side pockets, a 24-inch seat and a frame rated to 325 pounds. It is the heavier chair, and it is the one I sit in for three hours after dinner.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

How I Compared Them

I did not set these two side by side on a showroom floor. I took both on three trips this past season, two at a Tennessee state park with a paved pad and one at a national forest campground with a gravel site and a slope. I sat in one each evening and swapped the next night. I put the same tumbler in the cup holder, the same paperback in the side pocket, and the same 45-pound dog against my knee. I timed setup once and then stopped, because both chairs open in about the time it takes to set a mug down. Before that I tried the cheap route and carried a folding stool for a whole season. It packed to nothing and my back paid for it by the second hour every night, which is the reason this stopped being a conversation about pack size for me.

What I judged was less measurable. How my back felt after two hours. Whether I could get out of the chair without putting a hand on the ground. Whether the chair shifted when Biscuit leaned on it, which he does, hard, usually right when I have a full cup. Whether I was still comfortable at ten at night when the temperature dropped and I did not want to move. I kept a one-line note on my phone each morning before coffee about how the night before had gone, because by the next weekend I would have forgotten which chair had annoyed me. That is the honest test of a camp chair, and none of it shows up on a listing page.

A person walking a gravel path toward a treeline carrying a folded camp chair in a carry bag and a leash in the other hand in morning light

The Cooler Question

A 4-can cooler in the arm is either the reason you buy this chair or the reason you dismiss it, and I understand both reactions. Here is my read after two seasons with it. It is not a cooler in the sense of a cooler. It is a holder that keeps four cans cold for an evening because they sit in the shade of your arm with insulation around them. Do not expect it to chill a warm drink. Do expect it to keep a cold one cold until you finish it.

The second thing I would tell a friend is that the cooler arm changes how you pack. I stopped carrying a small soft cooler down to the fire ring. I stopped making the trip back to the SUV for a second drink. That is a small convenience that adds up over three nights. Where it costs you is weight, and the Coleman is heavier because of it. You are trading shoulder weight for fewer trips in the dark. I will take that trade at a drive-in site. I will not take it on a long walk in.

The seat is 24 inches wide and the frame is rated to 325 pounds. I have had a wet 45-pound dog lean on it for two seasons without a wobble.

Comfort on the Third Night

By the third night the difference is not subtle. The Coleman sits a little higher and the back is solid, so you can lean back and read without feeling like you are sliding forward into your own lap. The Cascade sits lower with a sling seat, which is comfortable in a hammock way for the first hour and less so when your hips start looking for support. Getting out of a low sling chair at 58, with a dog underfoot and a mug in one hand, is its own small negotiation. The clearest test was a cold night in western North Carolina in October, when the temperature slid into the forties before nine. I stayed out an extra hour in the Coleman and went to bed early in the Cascade, and it was not the cold that sent me in.

None of this makes the Cascade a bad chair. It makes it a different chair. If you are 30 and hauling gear to a site you hiked into, the low sling is fine and the packability is worth more than the cushioning. If you are 58 and driving to your site, the wider cushioned seat and the arms are worth more than the weight you save. Your knees are the tiebreaker here, not the spec sheet. I tried a stadium cushion on the sling seat for one trip to even things out. It slid out from under me twice before the fire burned down, and that is the night I stopped trying to fix the Cascade and started choosing between the two of them honestly.

The Dog Factor

Biscuit is the reason I care about a solid back. He is 45 pounds of Australian Shepherd mix and he likes to lean, usually against my leg, sometimes against the side of the chair. A sling seat flexes when he does it. The Coleman does not. The side pockets earn their keep too, because I can put a leash, a bag of treats, and a folded bandana where I can reach them without getting up. If you camp with a dog, you already know why that matters more than it sounds. The leash lives in that pocket from the moment I sit down until the moment I stand up, and I have never once had to dig for it in the dark while he danced at the end of it.

One warning for dog people. A wider seat with arms makes a chair easier for a dog to claim. I have come back from the water jug to find Biscuit sitting in my chair like he pays the mortgage. The Cascade's lower seat is harder for him to climb into, which is either a feature or a bug depending on your dog. Mine figured out the Coleman in one trip and has not forgotten it since.

What I Liked

  • 4-can cooler built into the armrest, plus a mesh cup holder
  • 24-inch seat with a cushioned seat, back and head rest
  • Frame rated to 325 pounds, solid under a leaning dog
  • Side pockets keep leash, keys and phone off the ground
  • Arms make standing up easier at the end of a long evening

Where It Falls Short

  • 3.5 kg is real weight on a walk-in site
  • Folds into a long rectangle, which eats floor space in a small SUV
  • The listing states no manufacturer warranty
  • The cooler arm holds four cans, not a day's worth

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the Coleman if you drive to your site, if you sit for two or three hours after dinner, and if you want your drink within reach without standing up. Buy it if you are over 50 and arms make the difference between getting up on your own and asking for help. Buy it if you camp with a dog that leans. It is a chair built for the part of camping that happens after the hike, and for most of us that is most of camping.

Buy the Cascade Mountain Tech if you walk in to your site, if your vehicle is already full of dog crate and cooler, or if you want a chair that lives in the back of the SUV all season without taking half the floor. It is the better chair to carry and the easier chair to store. It is the lesser chair to sit in for three hours. Be honest with yourself about which of those two things you do more, and you already know which one to order.

If you sit longer than you carry, this is the one

The Coleman Portable Camping Chair, with the cooler in the arm, the cup holder, the side pockets and a 24-inch cushioned seat rated to 325 pounds. Mine has been through two seasons of weekends and one very determined dog.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →